Choosing the right payment gateway is one of the most important decisions for your Shopify store. Whether you use Shopify Payments or a third-party gateway, your choice affects fees, checkout experience, fraud protection, and overall customer trust. Understanding the differences helps you pick a solution that supports your business model and maximizes profits.
1. Understanding Shopify Payments
Shopify Payments is Shopify’s built-in payment processor, designed for seamless integration.
- No need for external accounts or third-party setups
- Supports major cards, digital wallets, and accelerated checkouts
- Reduces the risk of checkout friction or technical issues
2. Benefits of Using Shopify Payments
Shopify Payments offers several advantages for store owners.
- Fully integrated with Shopify’s checkout and analytics
- Faster payouts and simplified financial management
- Access to Shop Pay — one of the fastest checkout options online
“If convenience and speed matter, Shopify Payments delivers a smooth, unified experience.”
3. When Third-Party Gateways May Be a Better Fit
Some businesses benefit more from external payment providers.
- Support for international regions where Shopify Payments isn’t available
- Specialized payment needs (high-risk industries, subscriptions, etc.)
- Alternative methods like cryptocurrency or region-specific options
4. Comparing Fees & Costs
Payment processing fees vary depending on the method you choose.
- Shopify Payments has simple pricing with no extra transaction fees
- Third-party gateways may charge additional fees + Shopify’s transaction fees
- International payments, currency conversion, and chargebacks may differ
“Choosing a payment gateway without understanding the full fee structure can affect profitability.”
5. Checkout Experience & Conversion Impact
Your gateway influences how easy it is for customers to complete purchases.
- Shopify Payments enables a faster, friction-free checkout
- Shop Pay increases conversions with saved address & card details
- Third-party gateways may redirect customers away from your site
6. Fraud Protection & Security Tools
Security is critical for both you and your customers.
- Shopify Payments includes Shopify’s built-in fraud analysis tools
- Chargeback protections and monitoring are centralized
- Third-party gateways may offer advanced or custom security features
7. Multi-Currency & Global Selling
Selling internationally requires flexible currency solutions.
- Shopify Payments supports multi-currency and local payment methods
- Shop Pay boosts cross-border conversions with localized checkout
- Some third-party gateways offer region-specific currencies or wallets
8. Choosing the Best Option for Your Store
Use these criteria to decide which gateway suits your needs:
- If you want the easiest setup → Choose **Shopify Payments**
- If your business is in a restricted region → Choose a **third-party gateway**
- If you need special payment options → Use a **hybrid approach**
Final Thoughts
Both Shopify Payments and third-party gateways offer strong solutions depending on your business needs. Shopify Payments delivers simplicity, speed, and lower fees, while third-party gateways offer flexibility and specialized support. The best option is the one that aligns with your target market, product type, and long-term growth strategy. When chosen wisely, your payment gateway becomes more than a tool — it becomes a catalyst for higher conversions and better customer experience.
I am the Founder of Crest Infotech With over 18 years’ experience in web design, web development, mobile apps development and content marketing. I ensure that we deliver quality website to you which is optimized to improve your business, sales and profits. We create websites that rank at the top of Google and can be easily updated by you. 
